Remembering what ‘good’ sounds like
On London’s South Bank there is (or at least there was – it’s odd to think that I haven’t been in London since early March) a large banner of the cellist Sheku Kanneh-Mason with the slogan ’You haven’t heard it until you’ve heard it live’. I think we’d still probably all agree with this as a principle, but circumstances definitely change perspectives and we now find ourselves very rapidly embedding ourselves and our music-making into a quite different world. As other articles in ABRSM PlayOn and responses to them have shown, despite its challenges, it is providing us with all sorts of opportunities.
As musicians we’ve embraced recordings alongside live performances for many a year, and some of us will be able to recount developments from 33rpm, through iPods and on to YouTube and Spotify, to name just a few. Now we’re teaching and learning on Zoom and Teams in our various rooms across the world and, as ever, we’re considering how we can best develop our playing and listening skills – and those of our pupils and potential exam candidates – through the various means available to us.
So, as a listener – whether we’re playing ourselves or giving feedback to others – how could we maximise the opportunities that we do have currently? Given that at ABRSM we believe in the five essential ingredients of Pitch, Time, Tone, Shape and Performance, why wouldn’t we start there? We’ve probably found in the last few months that of the five elements, Tone and Performance present the greatest challenge when we’re ‘on digital’; they arguably call for more ‘out of the box’ thinking. Yet the very technology itself that many of us are now using on a daily basis can be a source of help …
Working on Tone
Thinking of Tone, we may want to try any of the following and indeed, we may already be doing so.
- For the teachers amongst us, we can encourage pupils to send recordings of their playing in between lessons – they are likely to achieve more consistent sound quality than on the live online platforms available to most of us, and we are therefore in a much better position to give helpful diagnostic feedback.
- As performers, we can of course do the same thing and listen to ourselves.
- As an aside, I am often fascinated by parallels between music and the sporting world. Here’s something from the world of golf, in the context – would you believe – of practising inside a house during lockdown: ‘Another good way to look at how your golf swing is performing is to … record yourself as you practice. This will allow you to highlight…’ It then goes on to mention posture, touch and speed.
- Technique, of course, controls tone to a great extent – so it’s a good time to ‘go back to basics’ at least for some of our practice time and listen to the results
- Find something easy to play and concentrate purely on the sound.
- Try ‘sounding bad’ (not for too long, maybe, for obvious reasons!) and consider what makes it so before going back to the ‘good’. This could be fun for children to do for their parents …
- Listen to different performers online and compare their general tone and how it characterises the music they play (for violinists it might be Benedetti, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IM50kxByH94 Perlman, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPU0CAXTmVQ and Grappelli, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4kf5aU1Wtg.
- Compare different performers playing the same piece, the same movement, even the same passage. Try to replicate, share with others and so on.
Working on Performance
As for Performance – it’s a challenge to achieve the same sense of presence (not just in a literal sense) from digital and / or recorded playing and singing as we can in a room, but there’s no doubt that we can get somewhere near to it. A lot can be communicated – through video in particular – so what can we do in our current listening (and watching) to evaluate and develop a sense of musical communication and commitment?
At the most basic level, we should remember that Performance is in some respects a summation of all of the other musical ‘ingredients’. If the foundations of Pitch and Time aren’t in place, it’s unlikely that any amount of conviction, enthusiasm and commitment will result in overall musical success. This clip https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zEuQ5O5NUfQ will make us smile no doubt, but it wasn’t produced in the context of distinction level playing!
Let’s assume that the notes, key and time are secure. Now would be a good time to try out any of the following…
- Set aside time for full ‘runs’ of pieces within our overall practice – put the metaphorical ‘red light’ on and record, and then learn from listening to the playback. Did we really point that note or harmony as we thought we did, was the balance as convincing as we hoped it would be, how effectively did we work through moments where things didn’t go completely to plan? And so on…
- Think about how we ‘frame’ pieces. How can we best create atmosphere at the starts and ends of them? Does the music gain from a longer or shorter silence before and after it? Again, recording different versions might well help inform our view of how effective we have been. Listening to others doing it is also revealing, whether it’s a famous conductor setting up or completing a work or movement, or just a random performance on YouTube.
- As teachers, empower our pupils – at all levels – to take greater responsibility for their performances, including setting the speeds, leading us (as opposed to the other way round) whenever they can. They and we can watch, listen and play-back - to learn more about this aspect of performance that we sometimes don’t consider until later along the musical learning journey.
- Leave a well-learned piece for a while and then come back to it ‘fresh’. I’m clearly missing golf currently, as I also spotted this https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/golf/52655331. I don’t doubt that he’s a good player and has the sport’s equivalent of Pitch, Time, Tone, Shape and Performance well in place – and then he went out with renewed zest for the course and the fresh air!
- Consider and recognise the importance of musical Shape, another element of the ABRSM marking criteria, which is vital to convincing, vivid playing and singing. We can experiment with shaping, re-shaping, and re-vitalising melodic lines. This will doubtless pay us back generously in our future performances.
I had a sort of epiphany about this when I listened years ago to the then Winchester Cathedral choristers, under David Hill’s direction.
The trebles’ first two notes, alone, of Brahms’ Geistliches Lied made a real mark on me through their weighting and colour. Actually, I wouldn’t have needed to be there or even see them to appreciate the sense of assurance, musicianship and – even in the setting of a service as opposed to a concert – performance because of the shape. I can also feel it through their recording, so engaging is the musical energy and clarity involved in the first choral phrase https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1qyCyREx4Q. Incidentally, for those interested in form and analysis, the choral parts are a double canon at the ninth. Hopefully, I was able to instil a similar sense of ownership of – of more accurately passion for - melodic lines and their shaping into my choristers; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TS9Byegb7KM
- Lastly, let’s take direct inspiration from the Performance quality of some of our best-known musicians. There are numerous good examples of this on the web. Hereare just three for starters: the energy and engagement of Jess Gillam https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AD3WboFBkBY, the zeal and characterisation of Bryn Terfel https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6GH7I0TxILg and the communication and confidence of Lang Lang https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nv9GTZGp6fw.
So, there are many things that we can do to enhance our listening and playing skills in what is probably going to be the musical normal for quite some time to come. There have certainly been plenty of recorded performances to energise us during lockdown and the ensuing weeks, whether the NHS Choir with Lean on Me https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfbK9FBJ5BU, the BBC Philharmonic’s weekly radio challenges https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p08cjzlr, or the Ukrainian Radio Orchestra strings back on stage albeit behind closed doors https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xDt2RyOBjmM.
Maybe that London South Bank banner might, for a while at least, have a new slant and say something like ’You haven’t heard it live until you’ve heard it live, but you can definitely still hear it…” And come to that, why wouldn’t we want to listen to and watch Sheku’s recent recording? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7HbFLiufDq4